|
THE "STUDENT INFORMATION SHEET":
A Proactive Strategy for Initiating & Establishing Teacher-Student Rapport
Joe Cuseo
Professor, Psychology; Director, Freshman Seminar
Marymount College (CA)
In every course I teach, my first and foremost goal is to establish rapport with my students.
Similar to Maslow's need-hierarchy model of human motivation, I operate under the assumption that
meeting students' need for acceptance and validation is a precondition that provides the social-emotional
foundation for learning and growth. It has been my experience that students begin to care more about
learning and become more committed to the learning process when they sense that their instructor cares
about them.
Probably my most successful and potentially replicable instructional strategy for gaining
and maintaining instructor-student rapport is what I call the "Student Information Sheet." The sheet
contains questions for students to answer; the questions are divided into six general areas:
(1) personal background, (2) future plans, (3) personal abilities, achievements, and distinctive qualities,
(4) personal interests, (5) personal values, and (6) course expectations, expectations and interests.
(See Appendix A for a specific list of questions relating to each of these six categories.)
On the first day of class, I distribute the course syllabus, but do not spend class time systematically
reviewing it. Instead, I tell students that their first assignment is to read the syllabus for the next
class session, because I want my first experience with them to focus on people, not paper. I tell them
that we're going to take some time to learn about each other before we attempt to learn the subject matter,
then I project a transparency that contains the questions related to the aforementioned six areas. I reveal
one question at a time, and have students record their answers to each question on a sheet of paper; at
the same time, I write my answers on the board to the same questions (except for those questions that
are student-specific, such as class standing). By answering the questions myself, I show students that
I trust them well enough to reveal something personal about myself, which in turn, seems to make them
feel more comfortable about revealing more of themselves to me. Also, my answering the questions with
them serves to validate the exercise, suggesting that it's worthy of my time and effort as well.
This exercise typically takes about one minute per question, i.e., 50 questions takes approximately
50 minutes. If I have a 50-minute class session, I typically use no more than 35-40 of the questions,
because I want to reserve some class time to collect the information sheets and review students'
names. I like to keep the process moving fairly quickly by advising students that they can use single
words and phrases to answer the questions (as I do on the board). Also, short and fairly quick
responses can often capture students' true thoughts or feelings in response to the question (akin to
free association), as opposed to calculated, socially acceptable responses.
After the exercise is completed, I collect each student's information sheet and use it in the
following ways to promote rapport with the class throughout the term.
1. On the first day of class, after I've collected all the information sheets, I
call-out the names of individual students, asking them to raise their hand when
their name is called so I can associate their name and face. As I call their
names out, I very rapidly jot down a quick word or abbreviated phrase next to
the student's name for later review (e.g., something about a distinctive
physical feature or seating spot that can help me remember the student).
2. Before the next class meeting, I read all student responses to the questions
and highlight one from each student's sheet that is thought provoking or
stimulating. I come to the second class session with something highlighted on
each student's sheet, and I start class by calling out each student's name and
asking the student for a brief elaboration on the item I've highlighted (e.g.,
When did you move from New York to California? When you worked with handicapped
children, what type of assistance did you provide?) This shows each student that
I've taken to time to read their information sheets and am taking an individual
interest in each one of them. The short verbal interchange I have with each
student also helps me immensely in learning their names, because it allows more
eye-contact time than that which occurs during a simple roll call, and it
provides a distinctive event or "episode" to which I can relate
(associate) their face and name.
3. Throughout the term, I use the information sheet to actively involve
individual students in the course. I identify topical interests that individual
students mentioned on their information sheets during the first day of class,
record the student's name on a post-it sticker, and then stick it onto my class
notes-next to the topic or subtopic which the student had expressed an interest.
When that particular topic is covered later in the semester, I introduce it by
mentioning the name of the student who had expressed interest in that topic on
the first day of class. It has been my experience that students perk-up when I
mention their name in association with their preferred topic, and they are often
amazed by my apparent ability to remember the interests they expressed on the
very first day of class at points later on in the semester. Students rarely ask
how I managed to remember their personal interests, so they remain unaware of my
"crib sheet" strategy. Consequently, they tend to conclude that I have
extraordinary social memory and social sensitivity (which is fine with me).
4. I use one statement from each student's information sheet to create a class
community-building or peer-bonding exercise that I call, "The Classroom
Scavenger Hunt." (See pp. 7-11 for specific step-by-step instructions.) I
also use the student information sheet for the following purposes.
5. To make final decisions about course-content coverage. I will use student
interests expressed on the information sheet to help select course topics and
subtopics. For example, in a course like General Psychology, in which it's
impossible to cover everything, I decide on a set of core concepts or topics and
use information gleaned from students' sheets to decide on what remaining
"supplemental" topics I cover. I tell the class that after I've done
this, which gives them a sense of input into and ownership of the course that
may serve to enhance their intrinsic motivation.
6. To "connect" personally with a student who rarely speak in class or
who seem "detached" For example, I may come early to class and
strike-up a conversation with the student about something from their information
sheet. Or, as students leave the classroom at the end of class, I typically
stand by the door as they depart. When a quiet or non-participative student is
leaving, I'll quickly ask that student something relating to her information
sheet.
7. To connect my course with other course students are taking in the same term.
One question on the information sheet asks students for their current class
schedule. I make note of other courses that students are taking and attempt to
relate my course to other courses that students are taking. For instance, if I'm
covering mnemonic devices in freshman seminar, I will use examples for improving
memory that apply to content they may be learning in other classes.
8. To intentionally form small groups or learning teams For example, I may
create homogeneous groups consisting of students with the same career interests,
or heterogeneous teams comprised of students from different geographical areas).
9. To personalize my written feedback to students during the term. For example,
if a student initially expressed an interest in joining a student club or
finding an on-campus job, I'll ask about that by writing a "P.S." at
the end of the feedback I'm providing on a journal entry or exam).
10. To prepare for and personalize students' scheduled office visits. I will
look over the information sheet of a student prior to an office visit and refer
to something mentioned on the sheet during the office visit.
11. To personalize and enliven the process of returning student assignments in
class. Periodically, before a class session when I'll be returning student
assignments, I look over the information sheets just before going to class and
when returning their assignments in class, instead of calling their names, I'll
call out something from their information sheet. For example, I might say:
"Will a future occupational therapist from Maryland please come up and
pick-up your assignment?" (This demonstrates to students at later points in
the term that I still know them well.)
12. To showcase students' articulate comments and insightful ideas. I will look
for comments and ideas shared by students on their information sheet that may
relate to a course topic and display them on a transparency when we get to that
particular in class. For example, there is a question on the information sheet
that asks students for their favorite quote. One student wrote: "When you
point your finger at someone else, there are three fingers pointing back at
you." This succinct saying artfully captured the gist of projection- a
defense mechanism that I was going to cover in class. When we got to that
defense mechanism, I created an overhead transparency that contained the
student's quote along with her name and used it to introduce the concept of
projection. (This practice serves to validate students' ideas, plus I've found
that they really seem to get a charge out of being quoted; perhaps it makes them
feel like a famous person.)
13. To personalize the content of my exams. I use the information sheets to
construct test questions relating to individual students' interests. For
instance, in a freshman seminar test covering the topic of major/career choice,
I include student names on questions that relate to their particular major or
career interest (e.g., "Jennifer P. is interested in both Art and Business,
so she decides to major in Art and minor in Business. Approximately how many
courses in Business will she need to complete a minor in this field?").
Conclusion
It's been my experience that when students are aware that you care about them, they care more about you
and what you're trying to teach them. They become more intrinsically motivated, more actively involved
in the learning process, more willing to take intellectual risks, and respond more positively (less defensively)
to instructional feedback. The student information sheet has been my single most effective method for demonstrating
to students that I care about them as individuals. It has proven to be well worth the "sacrifice" of lost content
coverage on the first day of class because it creates a much more favorable first impression of the class, and
because it has the versatility to be used in multiple ways-throughout the term-to connect students with the
instructor, with the course, and with each other.
Appendix A
STUDENT INFORMATION SHEET
PERSONAL BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
1. Your name (as you prefer to be called)?
2. Phone number/E-Mail number (optional)?
3. Place of birth? Places lived? Presently living on campus (where)
or commuting (from where)?
4. What is your class schedule for this term? (Course titles and times)?
5. How many college credits have you completed? (Freshman, sophomore,
junior, senior?)
6. Why did you choose this college? (What brought you here?)
7. Have any of your friends or family attended this college?
8. Have you attended any other colleges? (If yes, where and when?)
9. What jobs or volunteer experiences have you had?
10.Will you be working or volunteering this term?
If so, how many hours per week? On or off campus?
11. Will you have family responsibilities this term?
12. Has anyone in your immediate family (parents or siblings)
graduated from college?
FUTURE PLANS:
13. Intended major (already decided or being considered)?
How sure are you about this choice? (What lead you to this choice?
14. What are your plans (definite or tentative) after graduating
from this college?
15. Intended career? (If already decided or being considered)
How sure are you about this choice? What lead you to this choice?
PERSONAL ABILITIES, ACHIEVEMENTS, & DISTINCTIVE QUALITIES:
16. What are you really good at? What comes easily or naturally to you?
17. What would you say are your most developed skills or talents?
18. How do you think you learn best?
19. What would you say has been your greatest accomplishment, achievement,
or success story in life thus far?
20. What three words do you think best describe you?
21. What would your best friend(s) say is your most likable quality?
22. What would you say are your personal strengths right now? What
personal areas you would like to work on or improve?
PERSONAL INTERESTS:
23. What sorts of things do you look forward to, and get excited about?
24. What sorts of things capture and hold your interest?
25. What would you say have been your most enjoyable & least enjoyable
learning experiences?
26. What are your hobbies? Fun activities? How do you to relax and unwind?
27. If you had a day, week, or year to go anywhere you wanted
and do anything you liked, where would you go and what would you do?
28. What do you like to read?
29. When you open a newspaper, what section of it do you turn to first?
30. What's your favorite movie and/or TV program (if any)?
31. What's your favorite music or musical artist(s)?
32. Is there anyone dead or alive, real or imaginary, whom you've
never met but would like to meet and have a conversation with? (Why?)
PERSONAL VALUES:
33. What's very important to you?")(What matters to you the most?)
(What is something you really care about?)
34. When you have free time, what do you usually find yourself doing?
35. When you have extra spending money, what do you usually spend it on?
36. Is there a motto, quote, song, symbol, or bumper sticker that
represents something you stand for or believe in?
37. If there is one thing in this world that you'd like to change,
what would it be?
38. How would you define success? (What does "being successful" mean to you?)
39. Do you tend to daydream about anything in particular?
40. Do you have any heroes? Is there anyone you admire, look up to,
or feel has set an example worth following? (Why?)
41. Who or what would you say has had the greatest influence on your life?
(In what way?)
42. If there is anything in your life that you would like to change
or do over again, what would it be? Why?
43. What would you like to be said about you in your obituary or at your eulogy?
COURSE EXPECTATIONS, ATTITUDES, & INTERESTS:
44. Why are you taking this course?
45. When you hear "[title of the course]" what's the first
thing that comes to your mind?
46. What information or topics do you think will be covered in this course?
47. Have you had any other courses or learning experiences in this subject area?
48. Do you have any course expectations or goals? Anything
that you hope will be covered or discussed in this class?
49. Right now, how do you feel about taking this course-positive,
negative, neutral? (Why?)
50. Is there anything else about the course or about yourself,
which I haven't asked, but you'd like me to know?
THE "CLASSMATE SCAVENGER HUNT":
A Proactive Strategy for Promoting Peer Connections & Building Class Community
Joe Cuseo
Professor, Psychology; Director, Freshman Seminar
Marymount College (CA)
After 25 years of college teaching, I think that I have learned two important things.
One is that the first few class sessions represent a critical, formative period that
strongly shapes students' initial impressions and subsequent perceptions of the course.
The other is that there are three critical "connections" that should be made with students
at the outset of a course, namely: the student-instructor connection, the student-course
(subject matter) connection, and the student-student (peer) connection.
I attempt to make the student-instructor connection by using the "student information sheet"
(as previously described). I attempt to make the student-course (subject matter) connection
by taking about 15 minutes of time during my review of the course syllabus to provide students
with a "sneak preview" that highlights some of the more interesting and exciting course topics
or issues that will be discussed during the term, and by seeking students' written input on
topics that interest them. Lastly, I attempt to promote the student-student (peer)
connection by a class-community building or peer bonding exercise that I call, "The Classroom Scavenger Hunt."
This classroom exercise is designed to introduce students to each other, reduce students'
social anxiety, and build a sense of group trust and class cohesiveness. Step-by-step
instructions for this exercise are provided in Appendix A.
In short, the Classmate Scavenger Hunt is an in-class exercise that asks all students to get up
from their seats, move around the room, and discover the names and interests of their classmates.
Each student is given a "scavenger list" containing personal (self-descriptive) statements that
includes one of their own and one from each of their classmates, which I have drawn from the students'
information sheet.
When constructing this list, I intentionally pick statements that are distinctive
and/or humorous, but not too personal or private. (See Appendix B for a sample list.) Serendipitously,
I've discovered that students are almost always delighted or flattered to see something about
themselves appear "in print."
Students take the list and circulate throughout the room to find classmates whose personal
statements belong to them. They do this by pairing-up with a classmate, and each member of the pair takes
turns trying to identify the personal statement on the list that belong to his or her partner. If the
first guess does not produce a match, then the students continue to take turns attempting to identify
their partner's statement. The students continue to alternate this question-asking role until a match
is found for each partner, at which time the pair concludes their interaction and each member
looks for another partner.
While I provide oral directions for the exercise, I simultaneously project a printed version of the
directions on an overhead transparency at the front of the room, so students are able to hear them
and see them. I leave the transparency projected during the exercise, so the directions can be easily
checked by anyone who is initially unsure or eventually forgets what to do. (I find that this is a
useful strategy for any multi-step class activity.)
Before beginning the classmate hunt, I model what
students are expected to do by engaging in a short role-play of the exercise with a student volunteer.
Prior to starting the exercise, I also acknowledge that people who are shy (like me) may feel a little
uncomfortable at first, but assure them that previous students have responded very positively to this
exercise, and got more comfortable as it went along. I also provide the class with a rationale for
why I'm asking them to do it, and inform them that I will be doing it with them. (I add a personal
statement about myself to the scavenger list.)
Lastly, I thank them in advance for working with me on this exercise and remind them that they
will receive course credit for the final product they submit following its completion. The final
product turned-in by each student is a completed list, which contains the names of all their
classmates recorded next to their personal statements. If there is class time remaining after
completion of the exercise, students are asked to personally reflect on the process and briefly
describe the nature of their interactions or their feelings about the exercise. For example,
I've asked such reflection questions as:
(a) How did you feel about participating in this exercise when I first described
it?
(b) In the middle of the exercise, did you feel differently about it
than you did at first?
(c) Were you able to predict or guess what statements belonged to
different individuals based on their appearance and behavior, or were you
frequently surprised?
(d) Did you find any personal statement on the list to be particularly
interesting, intriguing, or memorable?
(e) Did you meet anyone in class whose interests or experiences were
similar to yours?
The time needed to complete the classmate scavenger hunt typically turns out to be about
one minute and a half per student. For example, in a class of 20 students, it should take
approximately 30 minutes to complete the exercise. If there isn't enough class time remaining
following the exercise to answer the personal-reflection questions, I ask students to complete
them as a take-home assignment.
Conclusion
The ultimate goal of the classmate scavenger hunt is for every
student to connect with every one of their classmates and learn something about
each of them. It has been my experience that such early peer interaction helps
to create a classroom climate conducive to student participation and
collaboration. For students in my freshman seminar, the exercise may also
address a primary need of new students at the very beginning of their college
experience, because research suggests this is a time when students are most
concerned about "fitting in" and establishing social ties. I believe
that the classmate scavenger hunt is a proactive strategy that addresses
students' initial need for inclusion, facilitates their subsequent social
integration, and promotes their eventual retention.
Appendix A
Student Directions for Classmate Scavenger Hunt
GOAL: To find classmates who are associated with the personal statements
listed on the provided "scavenger list".
1. Pair-up with a classmate. One of you takes the role of questioner-who
attempts to find the partner's description on the list-by reading one
description at a time until you find the correct "match." The other
person assumes the role or respondent-who answers either "yes" or "no"
to the description read by the questioner.
2. Alternate roles (the questioner become the respondent and vice versa), and follow the same process described in step 1.
3. Continue alternating roles until one of you finds the statement that matches the respondent. Then ask for the person's name and record it next to his or her personal statement on your copy of the scavenger list.
4. After the first member of your pair finds the statement that belongs to the partner, the second member continues to play the role of questioner until s/he finds the first member's matching statement.
5. After both of you find each other's matching description, move on to join another partner, and continue this pairing-up process until you have met and obtained the signatures of all students in class next to their correct self-description.
IMPORTANT REMINDERS:
*When you're asked a question by your partner, you can only say "yes" or "no." Please do not
tell your partner the statement that describes you, or take your partner's copy of the list and sign your name until your partner has discovered and stated your description.
* After your partner finds the statement that matches you, do not take your partner's sheet and write your name on it; instead, please say your name and have your partner record it.
*When trying to find your partner's personal statement, try to pick statements that you
think relate to that person, rather than just randomly going down the list. In other words, let's
see how good you are at guessing or predicting people's interests based on their appearance or behavior. (Take a look at the list now to get an idea of the different descriptions you'll be
looking for.)
THANKS!
Appendix B
Sample "Scavenger Sheet"
1. A sarcastic, former swimming instructor and future nurse, who intends to transfer to
Loma Linda University: _______________________________________________
2. A beach volleyball player who's good in math and would love to take a spontaneous
trip to Ireland:___________________________________________________
3. A volunteer coach and future teacher, who loves watching live bands and may
transfer to the University of Hawaii:______________________________
4. A fire-eating stunt man who would love to go scuba-diving and glacier-walking in
Antarctica:________________________________________________
5. A former scorekeeper and assistant trainer who's into sports management,
philosophy, and USC (Trojans)____________________________________
6. A Hawaiian surfer and future sonographer who plans to attend Seattle University:
__________________________
7. A computer graphics major who's good at math, loves the arts, and would like to
become a cartoonist:______________________________________________
8. A former swim instructor, lifeguard, and peer mediator, who wants to work with
kids-as a child psychologist or teacher.:________________________________
9. A criminal justice major who intends to transfer to Sacramento State University, and
would love to go to Japan to party with family (relatives):______________________
10. An outstanding water polo player from Sacramento who digs "wild paintings" and
punk music:____________________________
11. An animal lover who's almost always smiling, and would love to be a zookeeper in
San Diego:_______________________________
12. A dance major and business minor who hopes to own her own dance studio
someday:_________________________________
13. An extremely ticklish journalism major who's into science fiction and the
Simpsons:________________________________
14. An actor who wants to study film and theatre, and who's good at riding any type of
board on any type of surface (e.g., water, cement, or snow):____________________
15. Enjoys extreme sports and Italian beaches, but hates gossip and men who wear
loafers: _________________________________
16. A jazz and opera singer who would love to live in Florence, Italy: _______________
17. An introspective person who has worked at the Tournament of Roses and who loves
to talk about politics or history ____________________________________
18. Has done volunteer work at a home for battered families, and lives near
Occidental College: _____________________________________________
19. A lover of movies and fashions shows, who would like to transfer to New York
University:__________________________________________________
20. A bilingual future nurse who digs salsa and meringue music:__________________
21. A future film director with a wide range of musical interests, who admires Walt
Disney and unwinds by playing golf:__________________________________
22. A ballistics weapons expert with great running speed, who has worked as an assistant
manager of a film company: _____________________________________________
23. Comedian Rodney Dangerfield suddenly appeared at this person's house one day and
asked if he could put a billboard on the roof:________________________________
|